Thursday, July 23, 2009

Freedom of speech

Pictures

Hopefully the writing of this post won't get me imprisoned in the Netherlands forever. I'm pretty sure this post won't be illegal though. :p

At this point, you readers are surely thinking, "Wow, what could Pam possibly write about in a country where virtually everything is legal that could get her imprisoned?"

Well, I've decided to blog about the lack of free speech in this country when it comes to Holocaust denial and the banning of Mein Kampf. As you may or may not be aware, Holocaust denial and the reprinting, quoting, or selling of Mein Kampf, the work of Adolf Hitler in which he lays out his plans for the final solution, are both illegal under Dutch law, and in most European countries. And for potential legal reasons, I'm going to preface this post by saying that I in no way advocate the beliefs of Adolf Hitler or the Nazi Movement. These people committed terrible, awful atrocities under the guise of racial purity, an idea that has proven itself to be absurd, idiotic, and asinine. This post will purely examine the question of whether or not the government should have the authority to ban an idea, regardless of its ridiculousity.

The question concerning the legality of Holocaust denial and the reproduction of Mein Kampf is a tough one, but in the end I think that it's irresponsible for the government to try to stamp out an idea. Before you start trumping America's superior freedom of speech laws, first realize that the United States has its own laws limiting freedom of speech, such as hate speech or fighting words. I do think that hate speech and fighting words that advocate immenent or potential violence should be outlawed, out of protecting the safety of the groups that the words are being directed against. Total freedom of speech can potentially be dangerous, such as yelling "Fire!" in a crowded theatre.

I in no way advocate the teaching of Holocaust denial in school. That is a terrible idea, because education needs to be about facts, not about conspiracy theories or lies. But at the same time I don't think that a Holocaust denier should be jailed for voicing his opinions. It's true that Holocaust denying usually goes hand-in-hand with anti-Semitism, which can be classified as hate speech. However, I don't think that someone should be imprisoned simply for questioning the official position of the government on an issue. It's a slippery slope as to what the government will outlaw next if they start making ideas illegal. By keeping Holocaust deniers out of the education system, and by teaching children in school the truth of the atrocities committed by the Nazis, Holocaust deniers will be kept on the fringe of society where they belong, but there will still be a free flow of ideas and the government won't establish a precedent of banning ideas.

As for the banning of Mein Kampf: it's a hateful book full of lies. However, Adolf Hitler and Mein Kampf are extremely relevent in the study of history. I think that the book should be made legal, but explained in the schools as a book that lead to the killing of millions. Learning history is key to its prevention, and Mein Kampf is German history, like it or not. With the relegalization of Mein Kampf, European schoolchildren can understand just how ridiculous Hitler's ideas were, and develop a full comprehension of why Nazi ideas should never be allowed back in society. Again, the education of students is key. While nothing good ever came from Mein Kampf, I don't like the idea of a government banning books that they think are detrimental to society, no matter what their content.

So that's that. Hopefully Dutch policemen won't come to my dorm in the middle of the night now :)

1 comment:

  1. Wow. Induct you into the ACLU. :)

    And by that I mean advocating for the freedoms of the first amendment even when it includes things you disagree with. Good job.

    ReplyDelete